Adaptive Learning vs. Personalized Learning

Adaptive Learning vs. Personalized Learning

Adaptive Learning vs. Personalized Learning

Oct 27, 2024

What Is Adaptive Learning?

Adaptive learning, also known as adaptive teaching, refers to the use of adaptive learning platforms to deliver customized learning experiences. These platforms tailor content to meet the unique needs of each individual, providing specific feedback, learning pathways, and resources at just the right time. Unlike traditional, one-size-fits-all approaches, adaptive learning ensures that every learner receives the right support to optimize their educational journey.

How Adaptive Learning Works?

Adaptive learning technology is designed to emulate and enhance the expertise of great coaches and educators, not replace them, to create the best possible learning experience for every individual. This technology scales the benefits of adaptive learning to accommodate tens, hundreds, or even thousands of learners across various industries.

The way adaptive learning platforms adjust to individuals can vary, and these variations fall into two main approaches:

Designed Adaptivity

This method involves an expert or educator crafting a teaching sequence to guide individuals toward mastering content. The expert controls how lessons adapt, including feedback and content sequences, based on specific factors known as adaptivity factors.

In this expert-model approach, technology is programmed to respond in unique situations using an "If THIS, then THAT" framework. It can offer remediation when needed, provide advanced content to high-performing individuals, or encourage those moving too quickly to slow down. This approach gives experts significant control and agency over the learning experience, allowing them to customize adaptive learning platforms to fit their needs.

Algorithmic Adaptivity

This method relies on algorithms to answer two critical questions:

  1. What does the individual 'know'?

  2. What should the individual experience next?

Based on these answers, the algorithm selects the most suitable content at the right moment. Common algorithms include Bayesian Knowledge Tracing (BKT), which estimates the rate of learning, and Item Response Theory (IRT), used to model how individuals interact with specific items.

Through these algorithms and preset rules, adaptive learning platforms adjust content to the specific needs of individuals—just as a coach would during personalized sessions—offering remediation, additional content, encouragement, and more, exactly when needed.

Pros and Cons of Adaptive Learning

Pros of Adaptive Learning:

  • Personalized Recommendations: Offers tailored suggestions for learning materials and activities based on individual needs.

  • Focused Skill Improvement: Helps learners identify specific areas for improvement, accelerating skill and knowledge development.

  • Enhanced Engagement: Provides a more interactive and engaging experience than traditional classroom learning.

Cons of Adaptive Learning:

  • Data-Intensive Requirements: Requires extensive data collection and analysis, which can be challenging to manage.

  • High Development Costs: Can be expensive to develop and implement, requiring significant technological investment.

Learn about How is AI Changing the Future of Coaching Business?
Learn about How AI Chatbots are Expanding the Reach of Professional Coaches?

What Is Personalized Learning Definition?

Personalized learning is an educational approach that centers on the individual needs, interests, and goals of each learner. Unlike adaptive learning, where technology adjusts the content based on predefined algorithms, personalized learning empowers individuals to take an active role in designing their own learning experiences. Learners have more control over what, how, and when they learn, tailoring their education to align with their personal interests and career objectives. This approach encourages self-directed learning and allows for greater flexibility, ensuring that the learning experience is customized to each person's unique preferences and needs.

How Personalized Learning Works?

Personalized learning adapts to the unique needs, goals, and preferences of each learner. While there are endless ways to customize learning programs, certain foundational components are key to creating an effective personalized learning experience:

  1. Learner Profiles
    A central element of personalized learning is the creation of detailed learner profiles. These profiles capture essential information such as learning background, preferences, goals, and assessments. These insights allow for targeted support throughout the learner’s journey, ensuring that each individual's needs are addressed.

  2. Customized Learning Paths
    Personalized learning is driven by individual learning paths, which guide learners through specific activities and milestones. These paths are tailored to each learner’s role, goals, and starting point, providing a clear roadmap to success. For example, role-based training programs can accelerate new hires’ proficiency and align learning with organizational goals.

  3. Competency-Based Progression
    In personalized learning, learners progress at their own pace based on their mastery of specific competencies rather than moving through a standardized schedule. Regular assessments help determine when learners are ready to advance, allowing them to avoid information overload and focus on mastering tasks before progressing.

  4. Data-Driven Instruction
    Data is the foundation of personalized learning. Insights from assessments, evaluations, and screenings allow learning and development (L&D) teams to identify areas where individuals need more or less focus. This data-driven approach ensures that learning paths are continuously adapted to fit the learner’s needs, reducing guesswork and eliminating redundancies.

  5. Flexible Learning Environments
    Flexible learning environments—whether digital or in person—are crucial for personalized learning. These environments allow learners to engage with content in relaxed, comfortable settings, which reduces stress and distractions. This flexibility empowers learners to take control of their learning journey and progress at their own pace.

Pros and Cons of Personalized Learning

Pros of Personalized Learning:

  • Motivation and Engagement: Allows learners to pursue their own goals and interests, making the learning experience more motivating and engaging.

  • Flexibility and Adaptability: Provides flexibility, enabling individuals to learn at their own pace and in their preferred way.

  • Skill Development: Fosters creativity, critical thinking, and problem-solving skills by encouraging self-directed learning.

Cons of Personalized Learning:

  • Implementation Challenges: Can be difficult to execute in large groups or environments with limited resources.

  • Resource-Intensive: Requires substantial planning and preparation to ensure learners have access to necessary resources and support to achieve their goals.

The Differences Between Adaptive Learning and Personalized Learning

While adaptive and personalized learning share some similarities, they have several key differences that set them apart.

The primary difference lies in the learner's role in shaping their learning experience. In adaptive learning, the system automatically adjusts to the learner’s needs, making recommendations for materials and activities based on data collected about their strengths and weaknesses. In contrast, in personalized learning, the learner takes an active role, designing their learning journey based on their own interests, goals, and needs.

Another significant difference is the use of data and analytics. Adaptive learning heavily relies on data-driven algorithms to monitor learner performance and behavior, tailoring content accordingly. It uses this data to make ongoing adjustments to the learning process. In personalized learning, the approach is more reliant on learner inputs, feedback, and self-direction, allowing the individual to shape their experience without as much dependence on complex analytics.

Want to customize an AI Learning Companion for your students?

Discover how easy it is with a live demo. Click the button to see Curiously™ in action!

Want to customize an AI Learning Companion for your students?

Discover how easy it is with a live demo. Click the button to see Curiously™ in action!

Want to customize an AI Learning Companion for your students?

Discover how easy it is with a live demo. Click the button to see Curiously™ in action!